Women at Work - We’re Beyond Stretched
Summary
本期节目讨论新冠疫情如何放大职业女性原本就承担的大量隐形劳动,包括育儿、家务、情绪照护和家庭管理。来自不同国家的女性讲述了孤独、内疚、文化期待和无休止工作日带来的压力,她们即使已经精疲力竭,仍觉得自己没有资格抱怨。社会学家阿利亚·哈米德·拉奥指出,危机往往不会自动促进家庭分工平等,反而会强化“男性养家、女性照护”的传统模式,并可能长期损害女性的再就业、收入和财富积累。她的研究还显示,失业男性的求职会被视为对家庭的充分贡献,而失业女性却常因道德义务感承担更多无偿劳动。节目认为,女性为了同时维持有偿工作和家庭责任,最先牺牲的通常不是工作表现或对子女的照顾,而是睡眠、心理健康和身体健康。嘉宾鲁奇卡·图尔西安强调,管理者必须承认这不是“照常营业”,主动降低不现实的目标、提供真正可信的灵活性,并特别支持具有边缘化身份的员工。她们也建议女性放弃“超级女性”的标准,允许自己拒绝额外任务、重新协商家庭分工,并定期询问“我需要什么”。节目最终将居家办公重新定义为“身处疫情之中并努力工作”,呼吁个人、伴侣和管理者通过坦诚对话,把这场危机转化为建立同理心和推动结构性改变的机会。
Highlights
-
I'm expected to be the good Mexican daughter. Care for her, take care of her, but be respectful to my traditions, not talk back, not talk back to my fiance, be the model of the home, be the strength, be the pillar, and faithful to God and faithful to my studies, but at no point i ...
大家期待我做一个“好墨西哥女儿”:照顾母亲、尊重传统、不顶嘴、不反驳未婚夫,成为家庭的榜样、力量和支柱,同时忠于上帝和学业;但从来没有人考虑我的心理健康。
A vivid account of intersecting cultural pressures -
Unemployed men who are sitting at home and who are job searching are kind of quote-unquote working that way. Their wives are working full-time and they're still taking care of the cooking, the cleaning, managing children's activities and their calendars. With unemployed women, it ...
失业男性待在家里找工作,就会被视为以这种方式在“工作”;他们的妻子即使全职上班,仍要负责做饭、清洁和管理孩子的活动与日程。可失业女性却会认为,既然自己在家,就必须通过家务和照护来为家庭作贡献。
Research exposes a stark gendered double standard -
I think what's going to get lost is sleep. I think it's going to be mental health. I think it's going to be physical health that's going to suffer here. I don't have any evidence to suggest that women's paid work will suffer, or their attention on their kids will necessarily suff ...
我认为最先失去的会是睡眠,心理健康和身体健康也会受损。我没有证据表明女性的有偿工作会受影响,也没有证据表明她们对孩子的关注必然会减少,但我认为下降的会是她们的自我照顾。
A sobering prediction about the hidden cost of coping -
The biggest difference between an ineffective manager and an empathetic and inclusive leader is going to be those who can really speak to those anxieties to their team. They can say, look, I know we had set these targets on January 5th, 2020, and those targets are not going to be ...
低效管理者与富有同理心、包容的领导者之间最大的区别,在于后者能真正回应团队的焦虑。他们会说:我知道我们在2020年1月5日定下了这些目标,现在它们无法实现;没关系,你不必再为此负责。
A concrete test of empathetic leadership -
We're not working from home. We are at home in a pandemic trying to work. It's a very different framing. Whether it's your productivity at work or turning into the best baker in the world, those things absolutely need to be on hold right now.
我们不是在家办公,而是身处疫情之中,在家努力工作。这是一种完全不同的理解方式。无论是工作效率,还是把自己变成世界上最棒的烘焙师,这些目标现在都绝对应当暂停。
A memorable reframing of pandemic productivity
Full transcript
I'm showing up at best 50% of the time. The organization I work for has been very empathetic in understanding that there's not just me. There's many men and women who are at home, young children, sage children, and trying to do their best to now homeschool and be present at work. And so there's an understanding, thankfully. So that's been breeding its own inner imposed guilt, because I like to show up 100%.
And so when I can't, it's been really stressful. And then obviously, we get upset, we get worked up, and our kids feel that energy. So it's this sort of continuous cycle of this guilt and hurt in my heart. You're listening to Women at Work from Harvard Business Review. I'm Amy Bernstein. I'm Amy Gallo. As we just heard, managing work has gotten a lot more intense for many of us.
And amid this global crisis, it's comforting to be starting our fifth season, knowing that over the next several weeks we'll have this space to process what's going on and how it's affecting us professionally and personally. In this episode, we're coming to grips with the new pressures this crisis is placing on women, many of whom were stretched thin already. We'll talk about how to handle the extra emotional labor, family management, and self-sacrifice a lot of people expect from us.
This past week, we asked women to tell us about the pressures they've been facing lately. Here's what they said. I feel very lucky, but I also feel very, very, very stressed regarding the people that I love. And I don't know if they're going to be fine. I don't know when this is going to end. And I am alone the entire day. So I've been alone for three weeks now. And it's hard to be alone. And I feel like I cannot.
Say anything bad about it. I cannot complain or I cannot voice out this anxiety because I shouldn't be anxious I have a job so I think also my friends and family they I am their go-to person to talk about their fears and their oh What are they going through? So I just I kind of like just swallow my my my anxiety and a bit of my my pain and just try to stay positive for the people that are actually suffering, but much worse than I am. I pretty much had the day on my own to myself doing what I wanted, cooking what I wanted. Now, the restaurants are closed down. There is no place you can order in from, so they need variety. And I find myself plugging away in the kitchen quite, I think, almost double the time or more than that than what I used to do earlier.
I had enough of it initially, I said, okay, we'll do this, but if you each pull in your weight, and that happened for all of two days before they decided they didn't want any part of cleaning or shopping or whatever. So, yeah, then I said, okay, I'm not going to be taken for granted by you guys. So each person sent for himself or herself, but then after burned food, burned hands, I decided I'll make it easier on me and just do all the work all around.
something which is the pressure. I'm waiting for the offices to open so that they are out of my hair. We try to set boundaries about understanding when mom is on a meeting or if mom has a time blacked out, that's really important. But that doesn't always, that's not a perfect role right now. I think one of the biggest impact I've seen and I never saw this coming was the cultural pressure. Now, I'm back in the home and my mother's here with me, so I'm expected to be the good Mexican daughter. Care for her, take care of her, but be, you know, respectful to my traditions, not talk back, not talk back to my fiance, be the model of the home, be the strength, be the pillar, and faithful to God and faithful to my studies, but at no point is like mental health ever considered or
you know how I'm feeling for personal attainment or what that the collapsing economy means for my future that I have invested literally a decade of my life pursuing. We've had this traditional traditional role throughout our whole marriage and particularly when the children were little and this situation now has just intensified all of it because he feels even more so that he needs to be doing his job really well for the people that work for him as well as keeping his own job. And that takes all the focus away from what's happening in the family. And so, you know, here I am just figuring it out, trying not to go insane. So my emails, my phone calls, everything will finish up at 10 after I put the kids to bed or after we had dinner.
So our days are longer and that's something that I'm hearing from every single female is their days really long. They don't have an end and they're all blending into one. I'm exhausted, I go to bed and I just crash to start all over again the next day. I'm so glad we were able to hear from women about what they're going through and that they were willing to share their experiences. I mean, I've been reading.
about the impact on women of this crisis, but hearing the individual stories is just so eye-opening in terms of what's really happening out there. Yeah, you can hear the frustration and stress in their voices. Yeah, it's intense. The women whose voices you just heard spoke to us from France, India, the US, and Australia. And as we've been learning how this crisis is playing out for them and for other women on a personal level, We also wanted to learn what's going on at the macro level. Basically what this time is doing is making visible all the invisible work that women are doing anyway, but in a very kind of high pressure sort of situation right now. That's Alia Hamid Rao, a sociology professor at Singapore Management University. She studies the value of couples place on each other's work and how that influences who does what. Her new book is based on research she did on professionals who lost their jobs due to the 2008
financial crisis. Alias spoke to our producer Amanda Cursey about the damage the coronavirus outbreak is doing to women's work-life balance and the possible repercussions years down the line for their careers. Okay, so what we know from like past crises is that with something like the 2008 crisis, what happened after that less women actually lost jobs than men, you know, people called it the men's session in terms of the industries that are impacted, but the women who did lose jobs they had a much harder time getting re-employment and when they were re-employed they actually suffered greater earning losses than men. It was very negative in terms of their overall sort of lifetime earnings for wealth disparities in gender. What we are seeing right now, I would imagine but again something like that would occur with men and women.
who may lose jobs in terms of the economic impact and part of the reason I say that is because what these crises seem to do is they seem to reinforce for professional and managerial workers this very gender traditional idea of what it means to be like a family you know and what it means to be a family in these times of crisis really gets consolidated as sort of like a male breadwinner a female carer and you're already seeing that in women kind of writing about the kind of care work, the unpaid labor that they're doing at home now while trying to kind of work from home with sort of spouses maybe not taking as much care of kids or whatever it might be that the labor that's really pretty invisible is just kind of coming out very visibly during this time as both kind of couples work together at home. And so it's been about 10 years since the last crisis that you studied. Yeah. Has there been enough progress with gender equity so that
that the women don't have it so hard. Yeah, not at all. I don't see there's no evidence that there actually has been this kind of gender progress, even though it's been 10 years, that we would expect that maybe couples are more equitable and they share paid and unpaid labor more. We are not seeing that at all. Actually, when you look at the data, it seems to suggest that since the early 2000s, we've been actually either stalling when it comes to progress and key gender indicators are actually going back, reversing.
But how can you imagine this changing over the next few months? Do you think it's just like this is what we're going to have to maintain this labor, whether it's like emotional or other extra work? And is that just going to wear women down? Yeah, I mean, you know, it would be great if something like this would catalyze, like, you know, move towards more gender egalitarian division of labor in, you know, in households or whatever. I don't necessarily see that happening.
Certainly for marriage families with kids, I can say that I don't see that happening. I think mothers are more likely to say that even if it's short term or long term, this is just how things are. And fathers are likely to say, well, my paid work matters, and this way I need to do it. So this is not my responsibility. And part of this is because people set their kind of relationship parameters pretty early on. And it's really hard to shift afterwards, interactionally, like to kind of renegotiate. It can happen. It's just like not a very common response.
to economic crises. So like, as you know, I studied unemployed professionals, men and women who lost their jobs, and I did interviews with them, with their spouses, with kids, and I observed them. And what basically happened, what I found from that study was that with unemployed men, even when their unemployment had been going on for two years, which is very long, it was seen in the family as a temporary thing, right? So the family would not change their division of paid and unpaid work. So basically what you have is, unemployed men who are sitting at home and who are job searching so they are they are kind of quote-unquote working that way they're trying to get re-employed but their wives are in full-time occupations they're working full-time and they're still taking care of the cooking the cleaning managing children's activities their calendars and stuff like that that didn't change even over a long period of time what we saw it what I saw with unemployed women it was this kind of idea of well if I'm at home I need to contribute to the home to care work
which they were already doing more of before, you know, the unpaid work of cooking and cleaning and so on. They felt like this moral obligation that if I'm not bringing in an income, then I need to be doing this, which is not there for men. For men, it was very clear that the way I contribute to the family is I provide. So I mean, the way I would extrapolate those research findings with gel would like the broader research in this area for this crisis is that I don't see this kind of mindset changing, where it's just like, well, we are both at home and we both have work, paid work to do. And so let's kind of make this
Okay for each of us, you know having this work for both of us I mean I think what I'm gonna see happening is it's gonna be that idea of like the father sort of Quote-unquote helping out mothers with child care where you sort of it's not an obligation. It's not a responsibility It's a gift that you're giving but at a certain point Women are gonna get tired. Do you think that people will start dropping things? Like do you think women will be like I'm not gonna do this extra work like this is I'm done From the research that I know I don't really see that happening. I think like women often have like very high standards for themselves which they kind of commit to to the point of exhaustion and when I talk to these unemployment women when they talked about when they thought they might lose a job in the months before that for some even the years and like rumors started circulating in their industries of impending layoffs or whatever and they talk about like emptying up what they're doing so that they become sort of undisposable and with women. Well, how are these women gonna kind of keep going above?
and beyond for their paid work, whilst also managing all this elder care, child care, whatever it might be, you know, even the committed labor, if you're living alone, like managing the groceries and making sure you have enough toilet paper, whatever it might be. And I think what's going to get lost is sleep. I think it's going to be mental health. I think it's going to be physical health that's going to suffer here. I don't have any evidence to suggest that women's paid work will suffer. I don't have any evidence that their attention on their kids will necessarily suffer, but I think their self-care, I think that's what's going to be the thing that we see kind of going down. So you think that like women will try to keep together, like they're unpaid work, they're paid work, but internally we're just going to crumble? Yeah, yeah. Oh my god, okay. I know. But I think conversations like this can help. Oh yeah. I hope like, you know, maybe this is what we'll start doing more of. Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
So, Amy, after listening to Alia, how are you feeling about all this? A lot of thoughts. On the one hand, I think Alia is a pragmatist. She's being quite realistic about the situation that many women will find themselves in.
And on the other hand, I want to be optimistic. I want to be hopeful that there will be some couples, that there will be some women who will be able to renegotiate all of this. And that during this time, women will be able to find a way to save some energy and take time for themselves, despite what the research shows. Yep. That is an optimistic take. I still need to chew on it. Yeah.
Process all of this and to bring together what Alia just said and what we heard earlier from the different women at the top of our show, we talked to Ruchika Tulsian. She's the author of The Diversity Advantage, Fixing Gender and Equality in the Workplace. Ruchika, thank you so much for joining us today. Thank you. I'm so glad to be here. So I want to ask first, how are you doing? That is a very interesting question.
I'm dealing with a number of different emotions, as I'm sure many people are. There's clearly, you know, deep anxiety and grief. But there's this other deep feeling in the pit of my stomach, which over the last few weeks I've been able to identify as shame. And the shame relates to the fact that even though it's hard for me and my family, even though life has changed in ways that I couldn't have even imagined, i keep hearing these stories of people and especially women around the world women of color women with many other intersectional identities and the deep trauma and pain they're dealing with and there's there's a little bit of shame there that how come i get to have it pretty decent you know i have a supportive spouse i have definitely a rambunctious three-year-old but i'm really enjoying my time with him and so i'm trying to figure out how do i reconcile these feelings of.
my own personal pain and challenge of dealing with being a working mother during this pandemic. And at the same time, had I reconciled that with this guilt and shame that I really feel when I hear of stories of people on the front lines, those who've lost their jobs, there's so much pain all around the world. I'm feeling a lot of the same and even that question, how are you, feels...
Loaded and complicated and sometimes when people ask it I feel like saying great because at that very moment I am doing great For all the same reasons and you know to have a supportive partner I have a 13 year old who's doing great in school and doesn't need extra support I have a job. I'm keeping busy and at the same time if I bring my lens out just a little bit I just start to feel panic and overwhelmed and Really, I mean in a way overwhelmed by the suffering that I'm seeing everywhere I don't know Amy be where you you landing on that spectrum these days. I feel like I'm putting an awful lot of effort into limiting my feelings limited you know compartmentalizing I feel as if those muscles are getting quite a workout right and Yeah, I'll just adopt your your language when I pull the lens out when I pull the camera back
My internal optimist is at war with what I see with my own eyes and here with my own ears So there's that and then the other part of it that I'm very conscious of is having to control my own anxiety because people depend on me to do that Right, right, you know, I I do have to say that at this point that old you know the saying about putting on your own oxygen mask first that I think is going to make all the difference in the way that we cope with this because it's this is a long term this is this is long you know and and we don't know when it's going to end and so if we burn out now almost right at the beginning of this you know 18 months down the line we really won't have anything to give so I try and tell myself that yeah
I do think that the levels of burnout and emotional exhaustion for women in particular, given how long this could go on, are gonna be quite high. And one of the things I did this weekend, actually Saturday morning, Friday was a really awful day for a variety of reasons. And Saturday morning I woke up and I was like, you cannot forget to ask yourself three times a day, what do I need?
And sometimes that's basic like that's food because I forgot to eat a lot on Friday, right? Or sometimes it's bigger of like I need to put my phone down for an hour and go for a walk and not be available. The other thing I wanted to bring up because I think about it a lot, you know, there's the emotional triage of which, you know, which messages need to be responded to instantly and which ones you can put off for an hour or a day.
But I also worry a lot about the people who don't reach out and who don't ask for the connection because I think that this isolation gets us into a place where we're just working our minds in such toxic ways. Just the need to keep tabs on everyone at this moment.
does seem and not in a like evaluative way or accountability way, but emotionally just seems like such a huge burden. And I do think there is some responsibility to reach out to people who you haven't heard from, whether it's a coworker, whether it's a friend. And I hesitate to say responsibility because it's just adding yet another thing to do. But it feels like the right thing at this moment. And I'm glad you brought it up because It's easy to get into triage mode as you describe it and just responding to the requests that are coming in, but then we also have to think about who have we not heard from and how do we reach out to them? I mean, are you having to do some of that, Amy B? Yeah, and then the other counterweight is that the business context.
is very challenging right now. And a lot of figuring has to be done and decisions have to be made. So you have to find the space and the focus to handle the business part of your life, the management part of your life, in addition to the emotional caretaking, which I think is a very important part of what we do.
I really think that it's the most important thing as a manager, as a leader right now and we'll really make the biggest difference between when we get to the other side, the biggest difference between an ineffective manager and an empathetic and inclusive leader. Really the biggest difference is going to be those who can really speak to a lot of.
those anxieties to their team. And they can really say to their team, look, I know we had set these targets on January 5th, 2020, and those targets are not going to be met. And you're OK. You're off the hook for that. And the sad thing is, I'm not seeing that happen very often. I'm based here in Seattle. I have a lot of friends who work in technology. My partner works in technology.
And the overarching message is, you have all the tools to be able to work remotely. You are expected to deliver literally the same way. And I think a lot of these tech leaders have come out and said, no, not at all, not at all.
But I'm very much hearing that on the ground, the message is very different, you know, or at least individual managers are having very different conversations than whatever their CEO comes out and says in public. And it's heartbreaking, you know, women are having to manage young children and deliver at the exact same level as when they had a full set up of childcare and other help, et cetera.
So there's the expectation, like you're saying, Ruchika, that we produce at the same level we were three weeks ago, which never mind trying to do it virtually, we also just have all this emotional burden, our own personal anxiety on top of that. And I think there's a lot of pressure we heard from our listeners to perform even more you know even excel in this environment as a way to prove yourself especially in the face of layoffs in the face of an uncertain economic future I feel like that the pressure hasn't just been No interruptions. That's the message I keep hearing from people is like no interruptions business as usual, but then there's also the like Take it up a notch in this environment and show you can excel when times are really tough
I think that a lot of that comes from managers. I also worry that women sometimes place a lot of burden on themselves in this situation. What do you guys think? I agree at the same time. I see it so much more with my friends and people I speak to who are women of color or women who wear other intersectional identities in the workplace, you know, they may have told their boss that I'm dealing with some mental health challenges in the past. They may have become new mothers or whatnot.
Sometimes I think those extra pressures they put on themselves is kind of valid, right? Because the message they've been getting all this while when business was as usual was you really have to work twice as hard, right? We know some of the stereotypes that women of color deal with when it comes to being considered either incompetent or less reliable or lacking leadership skills. And if you're hearing that message communicate often in the workplace, then at a time like this when you actually can't see your managers, you're not meeting your team regularly, it's very stressful. What's your advice to women of color who are facing these dual pressures now?
My advice is more to managers as it always is, you know, to check in with people who wear historically marginalized identities and really, really make it clear that we understand the situation is unprecedented. We're not operating business as per usual and please let me know what you need. I want to ask about that advice you gave.
to managers to sort of ease up a little bit on the productivity. How have you been talking to your team around flexibility, deadlines, productivity? We're really lucky because we work in an industry where it doesn't matter where you get your work done and at what time you get your work done. So we have a certain amount of built-in flexibility.
about two weeks into this crisis I was starting to worry that people were burning themselves out. I was seeing them online at 8 a.m. and at 8 p.m. and I wouldn't want to see that in the best of times but certainly not now when everyone they're dealing with more responsibilities for more of their time than they ever have. And what I believe is that family comes first and that if we have to move a deadline we will move a deadline and we need to keep all of this in perspective that if you have a kind of a basis of trust in each other that you know no one on my team slacks off no one and I don't ever suspect them of slacking off so if someone asks for an extra day or an extra week or
for a little bit of wiggle room. I'm happy to make sure that happens. And we're also lucky that we work in an organization where no one second guesses that sort of thing. But we are lucky and that is privilege. Yeah. And I do think that the family comes first is hard for a lot of people, especially, I'll tell you, in the many hats I'm wearing right now, the hat I feel most competent in is my work hat.
So that's where I go to under stress and so it's very easy for me to just work and work and work because it's it's where I get a lot of great feedback It's where I feel competent right now and it's where you can finish something exactly. There's an end There's an end. Yeah. Yeah. Cause somehow the dishes never seem to stop. That's, that's for sure right now. But I think about those, especially some of our colleagues who have really young children at home. And I, and I want to ask you about this Ruchi, cause I know Aliyah talked a little bit about what it's like for people who have toddlers at home and the, and the pressure they're feeling. Um, let's, let's listen to what, what she had to say. Here, what you see is like, you know,
women sort of being like, I have to kind of pretend like I'm not at home because as soon as the toddler realizes I'm here, he wants my attention. So I just need to be super quiet on my meeting. So working from home, I think it raises these new kind of questions about, you know, who is seen as a professional, who is seen as prioritizing work and able to continue with work as when nothing has changed. And I think that's going to be easier for men to do that for women. So Richie, what did you hear and what Aliyah had to say?
Yeah, so two different points one is I think for women with toddlers this situation or with with young children That's not even say toddlers because I've heard it can actually be really difficult across the board But if you have children for whom you know if you say don't come in they're definitely going to come in and they're definitely going to try and disrupt the meeting that you have with their latest painting or whatnot I think the situation is really very difficult and it depends then at least for me it really depends on who's at the other end of the line and again back to this idea of like how you're viewed in terms of your competence and your reliability you know Amy B I wish I everyone I worked with had that level of empathy and inclusion
But the reality is I know in situations where I really have to up my game. And in those moments, I'll lock my door. I'll put up a gate. It'll be very, very clear that I cannot be disturbed because I really can't show that side of me, which is a mother to a young child. And then I take a very different approach in situations where I feel that psychological safety, where I know.
of me bringing a child to the frame, if he does happen to interrupt us, is not going to count against me and not going to count against my competence and ability to deliver on the project. So it's a pretty challenging situation. And across the board, I feel like it's extremely, again, important for managers to keep communicating that to women that I understand you're in this whatever situation you're in and I've got your back. It's going to differentiate the good managers from the not so good ones.
One last point I wanted to make is I really hope that managers don't assume that a woman doesn't want to do something because she has a child or she has elder care or she has other priorities that you know about and responsibilities. You know, don't assume that, you know, let her make that choice. And so the way that you could phrase it could be, you know, there's this new really new big ambitious project that we're going to embark on. I don't know if it's a good idea at this time, but are you, you know, is this something that you're able to do right now? You know, you have the full choice. It's not going to count against you if you say no. And I really think that sort of language and messaging is key right now. Yeah. I mean, one way to do this is to say, can you take this on and
Don't press for an explanation. You can say, can you take this on? It's totally okay to say no. Yep. I love that. It's totally okay to say no. And I think, wow, that can we like, that's our mantra from now on maybe. But you better mean it because I've heard people say stuff like that and not mean it and ding people for not taking the thing on.
And can we as women really, when we're offered that solution, can we actually take it where possible, you know, back to this idea of like, we don't always have to be super women. And if someone offers you an out, take it. That's hard to do. And again, because of the expectation that we either we put on ourselves or others put on us.
that we should be able to handle it all. I mean, dropping the ball right now just doesn't really seem like an option. And yet it feels like exactly what we need to be doing in certain areas of our life. And Alia said that when women feel all this pressure to do both their informal and formal work, what they sacrifice is sleep and mental health. And that's just not sustainable.
Yeah, it's not sustainable and then yeah and the pressure I mean I had a zoom call with some high school friends all women this weekend and afterwards and people were talking about what they're doing in quarantine how they're handling schooling how they're handling their work and and afterwards one of my close friends texted me and she said I just feel like I'm doing it all wrong. It broke my heart because I feel like we've just started The pressure when you look at social media my instagram feed of these moms who are like doing it all they have these crazy schedules and they're you know baking bread and they're you know like they're doing everything. It's the comparison is so easy to make and yet it's so damaging and if you were to try to keep up exactly like you said he may be there we would not sleep we would not take care of ourselves.
I will say that socialization is very, very deep. And we heard from one of our listeners who identified as a Mexican-American woman and talked a lot about the cultural expectations. I'm of South Asian origin. I grew up in Singapore. And it's very, very, very deep and very challenging. And sometimes...
For example, I'm like, oh, okay, now I'm home. So that means this is a great time to teach my toddler Hindi. This is a good time for him to learn how to ride a bike without the training wheels. This is a good time for me to perfect this recipe and that recipe.
week of being in lockdown, I actually was starting to see myself doing that. And now I've had to step back and say, that's unsustainable, right? And you are enough, you are more than enough in whatever situation you're in, right? If you get up in the morning and you make it through the day, you do not have to deliver and you do not have to be overproductive today. And that is still more than enough. Yeah.
I think that's a good exercise. I don't even remember where I learned it, but it's to, at the end of the day, my natural instinct is to look at all the things I didn't get done and to try to flip that and think about all the things I did get done. And sometimes that's feeding myself three meals. You know, sometimes it's getting one really critical edit done, but the to-do list at this point of all the things we could, should, want to do, Is so long and if you focus on that it's going to just put you down further and setting expectations is usually half the battle, right? Well, let's let's talk about these expectations because I think it's not just yourself and your co-workers It's also your partner at home who you might might be negotiating with and we heard from alia about in times like this Women's paid work is often taking a backseat. Yeah to men's and I'm curious just
What was it like for you to hear that? And how do we process that? For me, it was really painful to hear about all of this. This time is like no other. You have to recontract. If you have always been the person who did all the sort of housework and all the cooking, all the housework, all of that were managing schedules in the past, that was under normal circumstances. You have to recontract now. Yeah, and I think one of the hard things about that I'm finding is that for me and my husband, for example, it took us Years to get to the agreement that we have currently and that we both feel comfortable and it is a constant renegotiation But this situation has sort of made it all implode and there's it sometimes feels like we're starting
From scratch, I had a friend I asked how her weekend was and she said really hard because I had to admit to myself and to my husband that he was not carrying his weight. And we had to have serious conversations about what he could do to step up and that's not a fun conversation.
We're also in our house all the time with our children, so there's no privacy to have that conversation oftentimes. I'm seeing this across the board with couples, you know, whether they're different genders or same gender, like just this constant, who's gonna take on what? There's no outsourcing now, as we heard Aliyah said, there's just more childcare, there's more housework to be done. And everyone's exhausted.
exhausted and emotionally, like my patience is whispered in at the moment, like whispered in. So like having these conversations, which sometimes are happening typically in the therapist's office, you're out to dinner, right? Under the best of circumstances, these are hard conversations, but to have them now is even, even harder. And yet I feel like Ruchika, your advice of like, you have to have them. You can't avoid them. Yeah. I did want to say one thing that I think is helping me.
think about this is reframing the narrative. We're not working from home. I read this on, I think somewhere on Twitter is making the rounds. We're not working, we're not all working from home. We are at home in a pandemic trying to work. I love that. Right. And it's a very different framing. And so whether it's your productivity at work, whether it's, you know, turning into the best baker in the world, those things are absolutely need to be on hold right now, you know.
we were talking at the top of the show, you know, are the narratives going to change? Are the structures going to change? And currently we play a role in that. So it's not even about sitting back and hoping those changes happen. It's about us having the conversations about how it needs to change. Not that it's on us solely to do it, but by having the conversations like these, I think we can really make the optimistic view more likely and the pessimistic view that this is going to make things worse, not better, less likely.
At the same time, I really hope that people who are managers, I hope a lot more people who identify as men and people with sort of workplace privilege, they really have an opportunity to listen and see the collective sort of suffering that women are facing right now and develop that empathy or at least start asking that question, have that curiosity. Again, I'm hopeful because I don't think those conversations or that awareness was happening in quite the same way. And right now we have a unique opportunity for more people to ask those questions and develop that curiosity and build that muscle. Absolutely true. Ruchika, thank you so much for joining us. This has been a great conversation. Thank you. That's our show. I'm Amy Gallo. And I'm Amy Bernstein. Our editorial and production team is Amanda Cursey, Maureen Hoek, Adam Buckholz, Mary Dew, Tina Toby Mack,
Erica Truxler and Rob Eckhart. Next week we'll hear from a behavioral scientist who's studying how working at home and online because of the pandemic is affecting our well-being. She'll tell us what parts of this new way of working might stick and which might benefit women over the long term. Until then, take good care.